The ‘female legacy’: an inheritance of strength, inspiration and complexity. Tess Benger in The Great Gatsby at the Citadel

Tess Benger in front of a poster of the landmark production of Romeo and Juliet that launched the Citadel in 1976. Photo by Bailey Chin.

By Liz Nicholls, 12thnight.ca

Every time Tess Benger steps out of the elevator on the third floor of the Citadel, where she’s currently playing Daisy Buchanan in the lavish adaptation of The Great Gatsby on the Shoctor stage, she stops in her tracks. Call it a Theatrical Moment: it resonates with her life as a theatre artist, her choices, the way she works.

Brent Carver and Nicky Guadagni in Romeo and Juliet, The Citadel 1976. Photo supplied.

Across the continent from her Toronto home in the Annex, Benger finds herself looking at a dreamy, historic poster of the very first show in the new downtown brick-and-glass playhouse that would prove a game-changer in this theatre town, and a debut chapter in the life of one of the country’s most influential theatres. In 1976 John Neville’s production of Romeo and Juliet, starring Brent Carver and Nicky Guadagni as the star-cross’d lovers (with Tom Wood as Mercutio) launched this new Citadel Theatre downtown. Edmonton was ready and excited: Romeo and Juliet was 100 per cent sold-out, start to finish.

Nicky Guadagni, the Juliet in this seminal production was Benger’s mom. a cross-country theatre connection you’d have to call uncanny. And the mother-daughter similarity is striking.

Duncan Cox and Tess Benger in The Great Gatsby, Citadel Theatre/ Royal Manitoba Theatre Centre/ Grand Theatre. Photo by Nanc Price

Daisy, the long-lost beauty who haunts Gatsby’s dreams, isn’t the first time Benger has acted at the Citadel. Most recently she starred as as the wide-eyed Sophie, the daughter driven to discover the identity of her father, in a 2018 production of Mamma Mia! in the Citadel’s Maclab Theatre. But “there’s something about being in the Shoctor, being in the same physical space, the one my mom opened, that means so much to me!” says Benger. “I feel her with me so intensely. … Being a theatre actor’s daughter is something I carry with me into every single thing I do.”

Tess Benger and Patricia Zentilli in Mamma Mia!, Citadel Theatre. Photo by Epic Photography.

Suddenly a web of female connectivity and inspiration, nation-wide, seemed to open and find its light. Benger thinks of it as “the female legacy.” Patricia Zentilli, “who played my mom in Mamma Mia! (Donna the single-mother tavern owner of that musical), was my babysitter (when I was) growing up in Toronto.” Zentilli, incidentally had played Guadagni’s daughter in a Toronto production of The Winter’s Tale.

And here’s another little loop to a female lineage that makes a vast country feel like a true community for its female theatre artists: Erin Shields, the star Canadian playwright who adapted Gatsby for the stage in this commission, was one of Benger’s high school teachers.

Tess Benger, Daisy in The Great Gatsby at the Citadel. Photo by Bailey Chin.

Theatre, the most collaborative of art forms, operates on the mentorship principle. And Benger has found herself musing on the female lineage of her mentors. At the Shaw Festival, where she spent three seasons 12 years ago — age 26 and “a sponge” as her mom described her — her eagerness to absorb the wisdom of the women actors around her, lingers. Benger’s first role in Jackie Maxwell’s company was Dinah, the little sister to Tracy Lord, the spirited high-society magnet at the centre of The Philadelphia Story, played by the great Moya O’Connell. And “though the plays are very different of course,” Benger is struck by similarities to Daisy. “I felt Moya’s presence so strongly, stepping into the shoes of this sought-after woman in a period piece.” And that debut season at Shaw included Cabaret starring Deborah Hay as Sally Bowles. “There wasn’t one night she sang ‘Cabaret’ when I didn’t watch from the wings….”

“The women at Shaw, run by a woman, were the giants of that festival!” Benger says. “Moya and Deb, I haven’t stopped thinking about the female mentorship in my life, not only what those women taught me about how to act, but how to be a woman in this industry.” She laughs. “And now “there’s no turning back … from the women I play henceforth.”

To help support 12thnight.ca YEG theatre coverage, click here.

And that history of mentorship has, of course, included the inspiration of her mother, a busy TV, film, and stage actor. As a little kid Benger grew up hanging around green rooms in Toronto theatres, Tarragon, Passe Muraille, Factory among them, where Guadagni was working. “We had an open-door policy,” Benger says of their house and the community Gaudagni gathered around her. “Actresses were always wandering through the living room — to babysit, to run lines, for audition coaching…. My mom is Mother Nature; the way she takes care of people is in my DNA. There were female actors around all the time, because she mentored them.”

By the age of 10, Benger had made her stage debut at CanStage in Colleen Murphy’s Beating Heart Cadaver. At 12, she was in The Mother’s Saint at Passe Muraille. By age 13, “upset at missing games, sports events and dances, I retired from being a professional actor,” she laughs. Her dream? “To be a professional soccer player.” The decision to pursue theatre — it now seems inevitable to her — was that “any hard audition” is less pressurized and anxiety-inducing than being a high-level athlete doing a penalty kick.

It’s a rare and precious alignment when “the thing you’re most passionate about is the thing that pays the rent.” Not easy, even if, like Benger, you work all the time. She spent this past summer in Gananoque at the Thousand Islands Playhouse, doing the Jason Robert Brown musical The Last Five Years. In the last year, there are three Mirvish productions in her resumé, including Titanique and Kimberly Akimbo. And she was in the Crow’s Theatre production of Natasha, Pierre, and the Great Comet of 1812. Still, she says, the Great Gatsby paycheque is how her Toronto rent gets paid. And because Daryl Cloran’s production is a three-way collaboration between the Citadel, the Royal Manitoba Theatre and the Grand Theatre in London, Ont., with actors from all those theatre communities, Benger sees the vitality in ”working cross-country,” with new people.

Tess Benger plays Daisy in The Great Gatsby at the Citadel. Photo by Bailey Chin.

As for the role of Daisy, the woman for whom Gatsby would re-spool time backwards, Benger is convinced that her creation of the character, in multi-dimensions, has much to do with the “female legacy.” Daisy, she says, has surprised her, in the character’s strength, as a woman in a world run by men. “I just didn’t assume she’d be as powerful, and I don’t know why…. She’s in the novel just as much as the men. Did I assume she wasn’t intelligent and strong because she’s beautiful?”

Shields, the playwright/adaptor, has written Daisy a little monologue that has the character stand outside the play briefly and comment on her reaction to other people’s judgment, in the third person. “Daisy’s voice was just Daisy’s voice.” Every night at that moment, Benger says, “I can feel the women in the room lean in, and you can hear a pin drop! And the play is no longer the same after that.”

“Gatsby gave Daisy the world; he made a world for her. But what does it mean to put someone on a pedestal, not allowed to be flawed?” Discoveries like that give Daisy, and the way Benger thinks about the character — so often dismissed for shallowness and bad choices — back a certain agency in her life, as a woman in a male world. And they were valued in Cloran’s rehearsals, Benger says.

That poster image on the third floor is a graphic signal for her, a reminder of a female inheritance of strength and complexity, as she describes. “I don’t shy away from the hard stuff. And now I’m hooked in — to Daisy and her power. There’s no turning back!”

The Great Gatsby runs at the Citadel through Sunday. Tickets: citadeltheatre.com, 780-425-1820

This entry was posted in Features and tagged , , , , , . Bookmark the permalink.