
Troy O’Donnell and John Ullyatt in A Christmas Carol 2025, Citadel Theatre. Photo by Nanc Price.
By Liz Nicholls, 12thnight.ca
The official marker of “the most wonderful time of the year” in Edmonton isn’t the white stuff on the ground (mere accessorizing). It’s the return of the Citadel’s fulsome music-filled production of the most indelible ghost story of them all.
To help support 12thnight.ca YEG theatre coverage, click here.
A Christmas Carol, now in previews and opening Thursday, brings back to the Maclab stage, for the eighth holiday season, David van Belle’s clever adaptation of the 1843 Dickens novella — Scrooge as the flinty proprietor of Marley’s department store, NYC 1949 — along with a cast of nearly three dozen (including 10 kids), plus a live onstage band, with a secular songbook. It’s a veritable civic tradition by now, following as it does upon 19 Christmases of Tom Wood’s Victorian era adaptation at the Citadel.
“A mix of Christmas Carol veterans and brand new people,” says Lianna Makuch, now in her third “hap-happiest season of all” of directing the signature van Belle production (and a cast led by John Ullyatt as the steely misanthropist Ebenezer Scrooge). “But then, as she points out, musing on the difference between a ‘remount’ and a ‘revival’ — the one sounds like repetition, the other like bringing to life again — “the chemistry will always be new….” You are just not the same person you were; you’re a different person a year later. And asking questions like “who am I now? how am I encountering this story, and the world now? what does it mean to me now?” don’t go amiss, for actors and audiences alike . “It’s a marker, a place in time, a meditation on where we’ve arrived….”
There are challenges in revisiting a production (“reviving it out of hibernation” as Makuch puts it) with actors who’ve been in the show before alongside actors who haven’t. The story itself, where the frost-bitten Ebenezer is flung by ghostly intervention into a journey through his own past, is all about questions like those. And Makuch herself, an award-winning director and playwright (First Métis Man of Odesa, Barvinok, Alina, Kohkom’s Babushka with Joleen Ballendine), finds a dramatic new resonance in thoughts about us as “fellow passengers” on the journey through life. She’s expecting a baby in March.
“Bringing in new cast members is part of the joyfulness of revisiting Christmas Carol,” Makuch says. “It could be (a version of) the actor’s nightmare for newcomers.” But that’s not at all how it plays out at the Citadel, in the strong ensemble where Garett Ross, replacing Jesse Gervais, is making his Christmas Carol debut as the ebullient Ghost of Christmas Present (and “presents” as he says in his jovial way), along with Eric Wigston, stepping into Oscar Derkx’s shoes as Scrooge’s warm-hearted, adorably festive nephew Fred, who never stops reaching out to his snarly frost-bound uncle. “They’re wonderful additions to the Rubik’s Cube of the production,” says Makuch.
Here’s the challenge for a director of a revival: “There’s absolutely no reason to reinvent the wheel, but it’s wonderful to bring in new energy.”

John Ullyatt and Ivy DeGagné in A Christmas Carol, Citadel Theatre 2025. Photo by Nanc Price.
And as for the state of the world, and the place of Dickens’ great story in it, start with this: it’s been a confusing, chaotic, alienating time, to say the least. The invading forces of A.I., the Microsoft crash, the breakdown of air travel a week ago, the Alberta referendum and its very deliberate political intention “to divide us from each other.” The list goes on. The forces that detach us from each other, “as we lose agency in the geo-political world,” are many, and multiplying.

A Christmas Carol 2025, Citadel Theatre. Photo by Nanc Price.
“Why are we here? Why do we want to tell this story right now?” as Makuch and her cast have been discussing. Rehearsing A Christmas Carol again, she’s been struck again by the undiminished power of a synchronicity between live theatre, where real people share an experience with each other, and the thrust of Scrooge’s story. After all, his night of encounters with the Ghosts is all about the rescue of a man paralyzed in a kind of permafrost of the soul, so that he might reclaim his place at the human table.
And that’s what live theatre is really all about, “our joy and our responsibility as artists,” says Makuch. “We are ‘local people”, members of a community, sharing our story with the community.” It is a chance for us, multiple generations of us, to come together in a room, to sing familiar songs together. “There’s a warmth to that….”
As Scrooge says, humbly, to his nephew Fred and his wife on Christmas morning, “I didn’t know how to be part of a family.” What theatre and this glorious ghost story tell us is that family has larger dimensions, and more possibilities, than we might have thought.
PREVIEW
A Christmas Carol
Theatre: Citadel
Adapted by: David van Belle from the Charles Dickens novella
Directed by: Lianna Makuch
Starring: John Ullyatt, Patricia Cerra, Maya Baker, Braydon Dowler-Coltman, Ivy DeGagné, Garett Ross, Chris W. Cook, Cathy Derkach, Steven Greenfield, Alison MacDonald, Graham Mothersill, Glenn Nelson, Christina Nguyen, Troy O’Donnell, Bible Onanuga, Bhéy Pastolero, Michael Peng, Elena Porter, Emmy Richardson, Morrigan White, Eric Wigston, Voice of Julien Arnold, a 10-actor Youth Ensemble
Running: through Dec. 24
Tickets: citadeltheatre.com, 780-425-1820